top of page

Helvetica Light is an easy-to-read font, with tall and narrow letters, that works well on almost every site.

Home › Donut Guides › Ice Cream Guides › Best Ice Cream & Frozen Treats in Key West

 

Best Ice Cream & Frozen Treats in Key West

 

Key West is warm all year, so a frozen stop fits into almost any walk around the island. This guide covers local scoop shops, gelato, shave ice and the island's own frozen key lime pie on a stick, dipped in chocolate. Most are within a few blocks of Duval Street, plus a shave ice truck out at Smathers Beach.

 

By the Underground Donut Tour team · Updated November 2026

 

Craving donuts too? See our Best Donuts in Key West guide.

 

Want to taste the best of Key West with a guide? See our Key West food tours.

DUVAL STREET & OLD TOWN

 

Flamingo Crossing

 

1105 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040

 

A family-run shop on upper Duval Street that has made its own ice cream since 1987. Flavors lean tropical, with mamey, guava, soursop and strawberry hibiscus sorbet alongside Cuban coffee and lavender. There is no indoor seating, only outdoor tables on the porch.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Key lime ice cream

 

DUVAL STREET & OLD TOWN

● Vegan options

 

Wicked Lick

 

335 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040

Website  ·  Facebook

 

Wicked Lick freezes each order with liquid nitrogen. It opened on Duval Street in 2018 and is owned by John Smotryski and Amanda Velazquez. Daily flavors include Mexican Vanilla, Cookie Butter Caramel, Roasted Pistachio and Dairy Free Coconut, with seasonal options like Key Lime and Honey Tarragon.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Cold Brewed Cuban Coffee

 

DUVAL STREET & OLD TOWN

◉ OFFICIAL UNDERGROUND DONUT TOUR PARTNER

 

Mattheessen's Candy Kitchen (Duval Street)

 

419 D Duval St, Key West, FL 33040

Website  ·  Instagram  ·  Facebook

 

The Duval Street flagship of a family business making treats in Key West since 1993, with homemade ice cream, marble slab fudge and oversized cookies. It also sells frozen key lime pie on a stick dipped in Belgian dark chocolate.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Frozen key lime pie on a stick dipped in Belgian dark chocolate

 

Taste it on our tour →

 

DUVAL STREET & OLD TOWN

 

Key West Shave Ice & Frozen Tap

 

718 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040

Website  ·  Instagram  ·  Facebook

 

This Duval Street storefront opened in 2024 and serves Hawaiian style shave ice with a scoop of ice cream in the middle. Guests can order a set flavor combination or build their own, then add toppings like sweetened condensed milk, rainbow sprinkles or mini marshmallows. It also pours draft beer from a frozen tower for the adults in the group.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: The Duval Delight (Tiger's Blood, blue raspberry and pineapple) with sweetened condensed milk on top

 

DUVAL STREET & OLD TOWN

● Vegan options

 

Limes and Pies

 

802 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040

 

A key lime themed dessert and coffee shop on Duval Street selling pie, frozen drinks and scooped ice cream. Key lime and strawberry ice cream come in waffle cones, and there is a non-dairy option.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Key lime ice cream in a waffle cone

 

DUVAL STREET & OLD TOWN

● Vegan options

 

Rooster Treats

 

1327 Simonton St, Key West, FL 33040

Website  ·  Instagram  ·  Facebook

 

A walk-up stand at the Southwinds Hotel complex pairing soft serve with hot, made-to-order mini donuts. Soft serve comes in chocolate, vanilla, key lime, dulce de leche and a vegan mango, with 18 toppings and specialty combos.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Key West Sunrise soft serve, or key lime soft serve with chocolate sauce and graham cracker

 

DUVAL STREET & OLD TOWN

● Vegan options

 

Gladiators Ice Cream

 

407 Front St, Key West, FL 33040

 

A small Front Street scoop shop serving homemade ice cream and sorbets made with fresh fruit juice. Reviewers mention key lime pie, coconut, mango cream, and pineapple and watermelon sorbets, served in generous cones.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Key lime pie ice cream

 

DUVAL STREET & OLD TOWN

● Vegan options   ● Gluten-free options

 

Duetto Pizza & Gelato

 

540 Greene St #1, Key West, FL 33040

Website  ·  Facebook

 

An Old Town pizzeria that makes its own gelato, with 14 rotating flavors in the case. Vegan and gluten-free options are available, and pints can be ordered to go.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: House-made gelato from the 14 rotating flavors

 

DUVAL STREET & OLD TOWN

◉ OFFICIAL UNDERGROUND DONUT TOUR PARTNER

● Gluten-free options

 

Key West Key Lime Pie Co.

 

511 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040

Website  ·  Instagram  ·  Facebook

 

A dedicated key lime shop on Greene Street selling whole pies, bars and chocolate-dipped treats, and offering pie-making classes in the store. Its frozen key lime pie on a stick is a grab-and-go option on a hot day. It is a stop on our Haunted Key West Food Tour.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Key lime pie on a stick

 

Taste it on our tour →

 

DUVAL STREET & OLD TOWN

 

Key Lime Pie Bakery

 

412 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040

Website  ·  Facebook

 

A key lime pie bakery on Greene Street that also sells cookies, cupcakes and coffee. Its freezer holds slices of key lime pie dipped in dark Belgian chocolate.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Frozen key lime pie slice dipped in dark Belgian chocolate

 

DUVAL STREET & OLD TOWN

 

Mattheessen's (Greene Street)

 

614 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040

Website  ·  Instagram  ·  Facebook

 

Mattheessen's Greene Street location sells the same homemade ice cream as the Duval Street shops, plus cookies, peanut butter fudge cookies and key lime pie. It sits a few blocks from the Historic Seaport.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Homemade key lime ice cream with a giant kitchen sink cookie

 

KEY WEST HISTORIC SEAPORT

◉ OFFICIAL UNDERGROUND DONUT TOUR PARTNER

 

Kermit's Key Lime Shoppe (Elizabeth Street)

 

200 Elizabeth St, Key West, FL 33040

Website  ·  Instagram  ·  Facebook

 

Kermit's original shop at the corner of Elizabeth and Greene Streets near the Historic Seaport sells key lime pies, cookies, candy and sauces. Its key lime pie on a stick is hand-dipped in dark chocolate and eaten frozen like an ice cream bar.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Frozen chocolate-dipped key lime pie on a stick

 

Taste it on our tour →

 

MIDTOWN & NEW TOWN

 

La Michoacana Key West Mexican Ice Cream

 

813 Peacock Plaza, Key West, FL 33040

Website

 

A Mexican paleteria serving house-made ice cream, paletas and ice cream bars. The menu also includes chamoyadas, milkshakes, sorbets and snow cones, with flavors such as horchata, cinnamon caramel and Mangoberry-pop.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Horchata ice cream or a chamoyada

 

MIDTOWN & NEW TOWN

 

Tropical Vibes Shave Ice Food Truck

 

Smathers Beach, S Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL 33040

Facebook

 

This food truck parks at Smathers Beach, the island's longest public beach, and serves Hawaiian shave ice and Thai rolled ice cream along with acai bowls and Cuban sandwiches. Shave ice comes in flavors like blue raspberry, cherry, orange and pina colada. It holds a 4.7 rating from about 250 Google reviews.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Shave ice in pina colada or blue raspberry with sweetened condensed milk

 

Taste Key West's best on one walk

Skip the guesswork. Our guides pick the best of the best at each stop, with stories along the way.

Key West Southernmost Sweet Treats Tour →

Haunted Key West Food Tour: Sweet Treats & Spooky Stories →

 

Key West Ice Cream FAQ

What is frozen key lime pie on a stick?

It is a slice of key lime pie frozen solid, put on a stick and dipped in chocolate, so you can eat it like an ice cream bar while you walk. Kermit's, Key West Key Lime Pie Co., Key Lime Pie Bakery and Mattheessen's all sell it in Old Town.

 

Where can I get shave ice in Key West?

Key West Shave Ice & Frozen Tap on the 700 block of Duval Street serves Hawaiian style shave ice with ice cream in the middle. Tropical Vibes Shave Ice Food Truck parks at Smathers Beach and is a handy stop after a swim.

 

Are Key West ice cream shops open year round?

Yes. Key West has no real off season for frozen treats, and most shops on and near Duval Street open daily. Hours can run shorter in late summer and early fall, so we suggest checking Google Maps before a late night visit.

 

Which local flavors should we try?

Key lime is the classic, and you will see it as ice cream, gelato, sorbet and frozen pie. Coconut, mango and other tropical fruit flavors are also common, since several shops use fruit grown in the Keys.

 

Can you walk between the ice cream shops?

Most of the shops in this guide are within a 15 minute walk of each other in Old Town, especially along Duval, Greene and Front Streets. Smathers Beach is better reached by bike, scooter, the Duval Loop bus or car.

 

Related Articles

Best Donuts in Key West  23 shops by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Key West  13 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Chicago  24 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Boston  24 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Portland  18 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Seattle  22 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Nashville  19 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in New York City  23 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Washington DC  19 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in New Orleans  19 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Philadelphia  22 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Dublin  16 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Toronto  21 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Las Vegas  21 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Savannah  13 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Detroit  19 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Vancouver  24 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in London  21 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Miami  22 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Santa Monica  19 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in San Diego  18 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Edinburgh  16 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Victoria  15 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Charleston  18 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Brighton  13 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Pittsburgh  20 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Los Angeles  24 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Knoxville  15 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Austin  18 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Milwaukee  20 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in San Antonio  21 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Dallas  20 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Madison  16 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Key West Donut Tour FAQ  Stops, timing, kids and diets

bottom of page