top of page

Helvetica Light is an easy-to-read font, with tall and narrow letters, that works well on almost every site.

Home › Donut Guides › Ice Cream Guides › Best Ice Cream in Chicago

 

Best Ice Cream in Chicago

 

From a 100-year-old South Side rainbow cone to a window where puppets take your order, these are the Chicago ice cream, gelato, custard and paleta shops we send our own friends to. They are grouped by neighborhood, each with our must-try pick.

 

By the Underground Donut Tour team · Updated November 2026

 

Craving donuts too? See our Best Donuts in Chicago guide.

 

Want to taste the best of Chicago with a guide? See our Chicago food tours.

FULTON MARKET AND THE WEST LOOP

 

Cone Gourmet Ice Cream

 

1047 W Madison St

Website

 

Sean McGuire, who grew up in Belmullet, County Mayo, opened this family-owned shop in 2013, and the Irish theme runs through flavors like Irish mint chip, Guinness and Baileys. Soft serve flavors rotate, and any order can be topped with Lucky Charms.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Vanilla and red velvet swirl soft serve

 

LITTLE ITALY

● Vegan options

 

Kurimu

 

1159 W Taylor St

Website  ·  Instagram

 

An Asian-inspired shop near UIC serving soft serve, hard ice cream and bubble tea. Flavors include purple yam, pandan, black sesame, durian and Thai iced tea, and there is a vegan soft serve.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Purple yam soft serve

 

WEST TOWN

● Women-owned

 

Black Dog Gelato

 

859 N Damen Ave

Website  ·  Instagram

 

Owner Jessica Oloroso makes gelato fresh daily from milk, cream, sugar and eggs and rotates flavors every month. Her savory-sweet combinations are the draw, and the shop is open Tuesday through Sunday.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Goat cheese cashew caramel gelato

 

WEST TOWN

● Vegan options

 

Paulo Gelato & Chocolate

 

1058 W Chicago Ave

Website

 

Gelato world champion Pawel Petrykowski brought his Polish gelateria to Chicago. The daily case is split into classic, vegan, no sugar added and chef's signature flavors, with fruit flavors like passionfruit and raspberry.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Stracciatella gelato

 

WEST TOWN

● Women-owned   ● Vegan options   ● Gluten-free options

 

Vaca's Creamery

 

1436 W Blackhawk St

Website  ·  Instagram

 

Dylan Sutcliff and Mariana Marinho run this fully vegan creamery, churning oat, almond and coconut bases plus water-based sorbets. Everything is vegan and gluten-free, and it also sells ice cream cakes and pies.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Strawberry Shortcake Sundae

 

WEST TOWN

● Women-owned   ● Asian-owned   ● Vegan options

 

Sugoi Sweets

 

937 N Ashland Ave

Website  ·  Instagram

 

A small Japanese-inspired confectionery run by Elle Lei, a 2024 StarChefs Rising Star, and her husband Jason Rice. It is known for bonbons and vegan matcha soft serve, and its weekly mochi drop in warmer months sells out in minutes.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Vegan matcha soft serve

 

LOGAN SQUARE

 

Margie's Candies

 

1960 N Western Ave

Website

 

This candy shop and ice cream parlor has served sundaes at Western and Armitage since 1921. It makes its own chocolates and hot fudge, and the 25-scoop Royal George is the biggest thing on the menu.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Turtle sundae

 

LOGAN SQUARE

● Women-owned   ● Vegan options

 

Pretty Cool Ice Cream

 

2353 N California Ave

Website  ·  Instagram

 

Pastry chef Dana Cree, author of Hello, My Name Is Ice Cream, opened this shop in 2018 with Michael Ciapciak. It sells hand-dipped ice cream bars, ice pops and ice cream sandwiches, plus a line of vegan pops.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Chicago Brownie bar

 

LINCOLN PARK

● Women-owned

 

Annette's Italian Ice

 

2009 N Bissell St

Website

 

Annette Franko's walk-up stand makes Italian ice from fruit, water and cane sugar and also serves ice cream shakes and frozen yogurt. Open seasonally, from the Friday before St. Patrick's Day through the Saturday before Thanksgiving.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Passionfruit raspberry Italian ice

 

LAKEVIEW

 

Scooter's Frozen Custard

 

1658 W Belmont Ave

Website

 

A custard stand near the Paulina Brown Line stop serving vanilla and chocolate custard, concretes, a banana "splice" and Italian ice. Open seasonally, usually from March into early December, so check hours in winter.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Boston shake

 

NORTH CENTER

● Vegan options

 

Bartleby's Homemade Ice Cream

 

1943 W Byron St

Website  ·  Instagram

 

Rachel Kamins started Bartleby's in 2019 as an ice cream cake business and now runs a scoop shop with sundaes, shakes, ice cream sandwiches and build-your-own cakes. A full range of vegan flavors sits next to the dairy ones.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Honeycomb Crunch

 

LINCOLN SQUARE

 

Teddy's Ice Cream

 

2000 W Montrose Ave

Website

 

Ted Pirpiris opened Teddy's in 2022 in a strip mall his family has owned since 1968, and a giant pink inflatable bear sits on the roof. The soft serve is 10 percent butterfat, every treat gets a Teddy Graham, and the Greek-inspired sundaes use figs, walnuts and visinada.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Poseidon Swirl

 

IRVING PARK

● Viral on social media   ● Vegan options

 

The Sugar Hole

 

4146 N Elston Ave

 

A porthole ice cream window at the Color Club arts space, where hand puppets take your order and pass out cones. It serves vanilla, chocolate and swirl soft serve plus dairy-free pops. Open seasonally on summer weekends, from Memorial Day weekend.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Swirl soft serve cone

 

PORTAGE PARK

 

Ciao Ciao Gelato

 

5355 W Irving Park Rd

 

Two Italian natives opened this gelato cafe in 2023 and make the gelato themselves. The case holds 46 flavors, from salted caramel to strawberry shortcake.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Pistachio gelato

 

JEFFERSON PARK

● Women-owned

 

Chiquita Scoops

 

6140 1/2 N Milwaukee Ave

Website  ·  Instagram

 

Joel Gonzalez and Mireya Garcia opened this family shop in Gladstone Park in September 2025 and named it after their daughter. It serves 16 ice cream flavors, milk and water paletas, mangonadas and Mexican snacks like elote.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Ferrero Rocher paleta de leche

 

EDGEWATER

 

Lickity Split Frozen Custard & Sweets

 

6056 N Broadway

Website  ·  Instagram

 

A custard shop with a Metropolis Coffee espresso bar, retro sodas, bulk candy and baked goods. Vanilla, chocolate and a featured custard flavor go into shakes, malts and concretes.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Maple Salted Pecan concrete

 

PILSEN

 

La Michoacana Premium

 

1855 S Blue Island Ave

 

This Pilsen paleteria has sold dozens of cream and fruit paletas since 2015, along with elotes, nachos and tortas. It is open daily from 8 am to 10 pm.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Mangonada

 

CHINATOWN

 

Legend Tasty House

 

2242 S Wentworth Ave

 

A rolled ice cream shop with 21 flavors, rolled by hand and served in a cone with toppings. It also makes milk tea and smoothies.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Hand-rolled ice cream in a cone

 

BRIDGEPORT

 

Sugar Shack

 

630 W 26th St

Website

 

Nikki Panatera has run this family walk-up window since 2006. It scoops 12 flavors plus a flavor of the month, pours soft serve with 30-plus toppings and makes its own Italian ice. Open seasonally, spring through fall.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Funnel cake sundae

 

BRIDGEPORT

● Women-owned   ● Vegan options

 

Runaway Cow

 

608 W 31st St

Website  ·  Instagram

 

An all-vegan shop co-owned by Alison Eichhorn and Aaron Gutierrez, serving oat milk soft serve, sundaes, sandwiches and cakes. Open seasonally, spring through fall.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Elvis Sundae

 

BRONZEVILLE

● Black-owned   ● Women-owned   ● Vegan options

 

Shawn Michelle's Homemade Ice Cream

 

46 E 47th St

Website  ·  Instagram

 

Husband and wife Yahya and Nataki Muhammad run this shop, named for Yahya's late sister; he started hand-churning ice cream in his college dorm. The case usually includes several vegan flavors.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Banana pudding ice cream

 

AUBURN GRESHAM

● Black-owned   ● Women-owned

 

B&B Ice Cream and Candy

 

8238 S Racine Ave

 

Ellen Brazley opened B&B in 2016, and its mascots Grandpa Bee and Grandma Bee honor her family. It sells ice cream, Italian ice, chocolates and bulk candy, with flavors like bubble gum and cotton candy.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Banana pudding ice cream

 

BEVERLY

 

The Original Rainbow Cone

 

9233 S Western Ave

Website  ·  Instagram

 

Joe and Katherine Sapp opened this pink stand near 92nd and Western in 1926, and it turned 100 in 2026. Five flavors are sliced, not scooped, onto the cone: chocolate, strawberry, Palmer House, pistachio and orange sherbet. The Beverly shop usually takes a winter break and reopens in March.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Classic Rainbow Cone

 

ROSELAND

● Black-owned

 

Richard's Super Premium Ice Cream

 

11033 S Langley Ave

Website

 

Pastor Rickey Singleton has run this Pullman-area shop for more than two decades. Flavors include sweet potato pie, black walnut, butter pecan and peach cobbler, and it also sells Chicago-style hot dogs.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Banana pudding ice cream

 

Taste Chicago's best on one walk

Skip the guesswork. Our guides pick the best of the best at each stop, with stories along the way.

Chicago Downtown Delicious Donut Tour →

Chicago & Fulton Market Delicious Donut Tour →

 

Chicago Ice Cream FAQ

Are Chicago ice cream shops open in winter?

Many are, but several classics close for the cold months. Annette's Italian Ice runs from the Friday before St. Patrick's Day through the Saturday before Thanksgiving, Runaway Cow and Sugar Shack close until spring, and Scooter's usually closes from early December to March. Check a shop's site or Instagram before you go between November and March.

 

What is a Chicago rainbow cone?

It is a South Side tradition that started in Beverly in 1926. Five flavors are sliced, not scooped, and stacked on one cone: chocolate, strawberry, Palmer House (vanilla with walnuts and cherries), pistachio and orange sherbet.

 

Where can I find dairy-free or vegan ice cream in Chicago?

Vaca's Creamery and Runaway Cow are fully vegan, and Vaca's is also gluten-free. Pretty Cool, Paulo Gelato, Bartleby's, Kurimu, Sugoi Sweets and Shawn Michelle's all carry vegan flavors or pops next to their dairy ones.

 

What are paletas, and where should I try them?

Paletas are Mexican-style ice pops: paletas de leche are cream-based and paletas de agua are made with fruit and water. La Michoacana Premium in Pilsen and Chiquita Scoops in Jefferson Park both stock dozens of flavors, along with mangonadas and Mexican snacks.

 

What is the difference between Italian ice, gelato and frozen custard?

Italian ice is dairy-free, made from fruit, water and sugar. Gelato is denser and churned with less air, and frozen custard adds egg yolk for a richer texture, the style served at Scooter's and Lickity Split.

 

Related Articles

Best Donuts in Chicago  19 shops by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Chicago  25 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Boston  24 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Portland  18 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Seattle  22 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Nashville  19 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in New York City  23 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Washington DC  19 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in New Orleans  19 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Philadelphia  22 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Dublin  16 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Toronto  21 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Las Vegas  21 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Savannah  13 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Detroit  19 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Vancouver  24 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in London  21 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Miami  22 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Santa Monica  19 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in San Diego  18 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Edinburgh  16 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Victoria  15 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Charleston  18 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Brighton  13 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Pittsburgh  20 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Los Angeles  24 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Knoxville  15 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Austin  18 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Milwaukee  20 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in San Antonio  21 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Dallas  20 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Madison  16 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream & Frozen Treats in Key West  14 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Chicago Donut Tour FAQ  Stops, timing, kids and diets

bottom of page