Helvetica Light is an easy-to-read font, with tall and narrow letters, that works well on almost every site.
Home › Donut Guides › Ice Cream Guides › Best Ice Cream in Pittsburgh
Best Ice Cream in Pittsburgh
Pittsburgh takes its ice cream seriously, from walk-up soft serve stands that have been scooping since the 1950s to small-batch gelato and lactose-free ice cream sandwiches. These are the shops we send our own friends to, grouped by neighborhood, with seasonal stands noted and our must-try pick at each one.
By the Underground Donut Tour team · Updated November 2026
Craving donuts too? See our Best Donuts in Pittsburgh guide.
Want to taste the best of Pittsburgh with a guide? See our Pittsburgh food tours.
DOWNTOWN
◉ OFFICIAL UNDERGROUND DONUT TOUR PARTNER
The MilkShake Factory
314 Fifth Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Website · Instagram · Facebook
The flagship of the family-run MilkShake Factory brand (Edward Marc Brands) sits on the first floor of the Tower at PNC Plaza and opened in 2016. It serves handspun milkshakes made with housemade ice cream, sundaes and chocolates, under an oversized milk bottle chandelier. The company traces its roots to a 1914 Lawrenceville soda fountain and chocolate shop.
Donut Tour Recommends: Handspun milkshakes such as the Jake Shake, the Rusty Shake or the Chocolatier milkshake
DOWNTOWN
● Vegan options ● Gluten-free options
Millie's Homemade Ice Cream
246 Forbes Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Millie's was started in 2015 by chef Chad Townsend and his wife Lauren and now has scoop shops in Market Square, Shadyside, Lawrenceville and beyond. Ice cream is made with western Pennsylvania milk and eggs, with rotating seasonal flavors and vegan and gluten-free options.
Donut Tour Recommends: Madagascar vanilla bean, or a seasonal flavor like Vietnamese coffee
STRIP DISTRICT
● Vegan options
OddFellows Ice Cream Co.
1637 Smallman St, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
This Brooklyn-born scoop shop shares space with Posman Books inside the Strip District Terminal. It is known for unusual flavors and several plant-based options made with coconut or cashew milk.
Donut Tour Recommends: Miso peanut butter and jelly, or the dairy-free coconut mango sticky rice
LAWRENCEVILLE
● Vegan options
FRIO Creamery
4127 Butler St, Pittsburgh, PA 15201
This Butler Street shop serves ice cream from Penn State's Berkey Creamery along with specialty milkshakes. It always keeps three homemade dairy-free ice creams on hand and was featured on PETA's Nice Cream Trail in 2026.
Donut Tour Recommends: Penn State Creamery Alumni Swirl, or the dairy-free blueberry lavender
SHADYSIDE & BLOOMFIELD
● Women-owned ● LGBTQ+ owned
Leona's Ice Cream
5119 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15224
Website · Instagram · Facebook
Leona's makes lactose-free ice cream sandwiches and pints sold at dozens of Pittsburgh spots, and opened its own Garfield scoop shop in November 2025. Co-owners Katie Heldstab and Christa Puskarich also offer scoops, dippies and crispwiches made with brown butter rice cereal treats.
Donut Tour Recommends: Black sesame ice cream on salted tahini chocolate chunk cookies, or cinnamon on oatmeal lace
SHADYSIDE & BLOOMFIELD
Mercurio's
5523 Walnut St, Pittsburgh, PA 15232
A Neapolitan pizza restaurant and gelateria on Walnut Street that began as a gelato shop in Kittanning. Gelato and sorbetto flavors rotate and are sold by weight.
Donut Tour Recommends: Spiced hazelnut chocolate or cherry ricotta gelato
SHADYSIDE & BLOOMFIELD
Twisters Soft Serve Ice Cream
4210 Main St, Pittsburgh, PA 15224
A walk-up soft serve window in Bloomfield that also scoops Hershey's ice cream. The menu includes sundaes, milkshakes, candy flurries and Italian ice. Open seasonally, usually spring through fall.
Donut Tour Recommends: Italian ice twister (Italian ice swirled with soft serve)
SOUTH SIDE
Page's Dairy Mart
4112 E Carson St, Pittsburgh, PA 15210
A roadside soft serve stand at East Carson Street and Becks Run Road that has been scooping since 1951. Owner Margie Prusin offers more than a dozen soft serve flavors, Arctic Swirls and sundaes, including ones made with Nancy B's cookies. Open seasonally, usually March through October.
Donut Tour Recommends: Arctic Swirl, or a sundae served over a cinnamon bun
NORTH SHORE
● Black-owned ● Vegan options
Happy Day Dessert Factory
906A Western Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15233
Billed as Pittsburgh's first Black-owned ice cream shop, this Allegheny West spot is run by Galen Moorer and his father. It makes about 50 hard-serve flavors plus custard, water ice and almond milk soft serve.
Donut Tour Recommends: The Cookie Monster (honey vanilla with their grandmother's cookies and Oreos)
NORTH SHORE
● Women-owned
Butterfat Gelato
404 E Ohio St, Pittsburgh, PA 15212
Former scientist and pharmacist Lauren Brock opened this Deutschtown gelato shop in July 2026 after a run of pop-ups. It makes small-batch Italian-style gelato and dairy-free sorbetto, with flavors posted weekly on social media.
Donut Tour Recommends: Cannoli or salted caramel gelato
SOUTH & WEST SUBURBS
● Vegan options
Antney's Ice Cream
1316 Poplar St, Pittsburgh, PA 15205
A family-run walk-up stand on the Green Tree and Westwood line, owned by Lee Anne and Anthony Ciotti. It makes small-batch flavors on site that often last only a night or two, plus pup cups for dogs. Open seasonally, usually spring through fall.
Donut Tour Recommends: Banana cream pie, or whatever small-batch flavor is on that day
SOUTH & WEST SUBURBS
Sugar and Spice
5200 Clairton Blvd, Pittsburgh, PA 15236
A family-owned 1950s-style parlor on Route 51 in Baldwin that opened in 1984. It scoops frequently changing hard ice cream flavors and about two dozen soft serve flavors, and has a walk-up window in summer.
Donut Tour Recommends: Black cherry or grasshopper in an M&M-baked cone
SOUTH & WEST SUBURBS
● Vegan options
Cookie Cookie Ice Cream
1815 McKees Rocks Rd, McKees Rocks, PA 15136
A family-run shop in Kennedy Township, owned by Connie and Ken Feda, that trains and employs people with disabilities. It makes small-batch ice cream and gelato and serves ice cream sandwiches on warm cookies, with plant-based flavors available.
Donut Tour Recommends: The Fat Elvis ice cream sandwich, or stracciatella gelato
SOUTH & WEST SUBURBS
Sarris Candies Ice Cream Parlour
511 Adams Ave, Canonsburg, PA 15317
Website · Instagram · Facebook
The Sarris candy store's old-fashioned soda fountain has marble counters, chandeliers and brass-trimmed booths. Ice cream is made in-house and served in sundaes, banana splits and milkshakes topped with Sarris chocolate.
Donut Tour Recommends: A hot fudge sundae made with Sarris chocolate
NORTH & EAST SUBURBS
Glen's Frozen Custard
400 Pittsburgh St, Springdale, PA 15144
A frozen custard stand that has been serving for about 70 years and has a mini golf course at its Springdale location. The flavor of the day rotates, and a second location operates in Lower Burrell.
Donut Tour Recommends: Peach custard or the flavor of the day
NORTH & EAST SUBURBS
Brr-Kee's Homemade Ice Cream
539 Allegheny Ave, Oakmont, PA 15139
A shop on Oakmont's main street that makes its own ice cream and gelato. It stays open year-round.
Donut Tour Recommends: Red raspberry or chocolate brownie
NORTH & EAST SUBURBS
The Black Canary
276 Freeport Rd, Pittsburgh, PA 15238
A Blawnox coffee and ice cream shop owned by Rodney Burrell that scoops Kerber's Dairy ice cream. It also has a vinyl listening station.
Donut Tour Recommends: Dinosaur Crunch (blue vanilla with cookie wafer pieces)
NORTH & EAST SUBURBS
Kool Cones
8130 Perry Hwy, Pittsburgh, PA 15237
A North Hills soft serve stand with two locations near North Park. It serves sundaes, freezees, shakes and Dole Whip. Open seasonally, usually spring through fall.
Donut Tour Recommends: Raspberry soft serve
NORTH & EAST SUBURBS
● Gluten-free options
I Scream Shop
21 Yost Blvd, Pittsburgh, PA 15221
A Forest Hills ice cream shop serving gourmet flavors and shakes. It offers dairy-free and gluten-free options.
Donut Tour Recommends: Strawberry Pretzel Salad shake
SQUIRREL HILL & OAKLAND
Dave & Andy's Homemade Ice Cream
207 Atwood St, Pittsburgh, PA 15213
A tiny Oakland shop open since 1983 that churns ice cream in small batches and makes malted waffle cones on site. Every waffle cone gets an M&M at the bottom to stop drips, and rotating flavors are listed on a blackboard.
Donut Tour Recommends: Chocolate chip cookie dough in a house-made waffle cone
Taste Pittsburgh's best on one walk
Skip the guesswork. Our guides pick the best of the best at each stop, with stories along the way.
Pittsburgh Sweet Treats, Coffee & City History Walking Tour →
Pittsburgh Holiday Sweet Treats & Walking Tour →
Pittsburgh Ghost Tour: Haunted History & Sweet Treats →
Pittsburgh Ice Cream FAQ
Where can I get ice cream in downtown Pittsburgh?
Millie's Homemade Ice Cream has a scoop shop in Market Square, and The MilkShake Factory on Fifth Avenue serves handspun milkshakes made with its own ice cream. The MilkShake Factory is a stop on our Pittsburgh Ghost Tour.
Are Pittsburgh ice cream stands open in winter?
Many walk-up stands, such as Page's Dairy Mart, Twisters, Antney's and Kool Cones, close for the cold months and reopen in spring. Indoor shops like Millie's, Dave & Andy's, Happy Day Dessert Factory and Butterfat Gelato stay open year round, so check hours before you go.
Where can I find vegan or dairy-free ice cream in Pittsburgh?
FRIO Creamery always keeps dairy-free flavors on hand, OddFellows makes plant-based scoops with coconut or cashew milk, and Millie's, Happy Day Dessert Factory and Cookie Cookie Ice Cream carry vegan options too.
Where can I get gelato in Pittsburgh?
Mercurio's in Shadyside sells gelato and sorbetto by weight, and Butterfat Gelato in Deutschtown makes small-batch Italian-style gelato with weekly flavors.
What is a Pittsburgh ice cream sandwich worth trying?
Leona's in Garfield makes lactose-free ice cream sandwiches with house-baked cookies, and Cookie Cookie Ice Cream in Kennedy Township serves sandwiches on warm cookies.
Related Articles
Best Donuts in Pittsburgh 22 shops by neighborhood
Best Bakeries in Pittsburgh 23 bakeries by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Chicago 24 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Boston 24 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Portland 18 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Seattle 22 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Nashville 19 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in New York City 23 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Washington DC 19 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in New Orleans 19 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Philadelphia 22 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Dublin 16 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Toronto 21 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Las Vegas 21 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Savannah 13 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Detroit 19 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Vancouver 24 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in London 21 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Miami 22 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Santa Monica 19 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in San Diego 18 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Edinburgh 16 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Victoria 15 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Charleston 18 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Brighton 13 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Los Angeles 24 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Knoxville 15 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Austin 18 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Milwaukee 20 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in San Antonio 21 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Dallas 20 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream in Madison 16 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Best Ice Cream & Frozen Treats in Key West 14 ice cream shops by neighborhood
Pittsburgh Donut Tour FAQ Stops, timing, kids and diets

