top of page

Helvetica Light is an easy-to-read font, with tall and narrow letters, that works well on almost every site.

Home › Donut Guides › Best Bakeries in Key West

 

Best Bakeries in Key West

 

We put together this guide to Key West bakeries after years of leading sweet treat tours through Old Town and the Historic Seaport, from key lime pie on Greene Street to French croissants on Stock Island. Our tour partners Kermit's, Key West Key Lime Pie Co. and Mattheessen's are on the list, alongside cafe-bakeries with gluten-free and vegan cases, a Latin bakery and a bagel deli.

 

By the Underground Donut Tour team · Updated November 2026

 

Craving donuts too? See our Best Donut Shops & Bakeries in Key West guide.

 

Want to taste the best of Key West with a guide? See our Key West food tours.

DUVAL STREET & OLD TOWN

 

Old Town Bakery

 

930 Eaton St, Key West, FL 33040

Website  ·  Instagram

 

A take-out bakery in a historic conch house at Eaton and Grinnell that bakes artisan breads, croissants, sticky buns and pies on site. Breakfast and lunch sandwiches come on house bread, and it opens daily at 7am.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Key Lime Pie with a Gingersnap Crust

 

DUVAL STREET & OLD TOWN

● Gluten-free options   ● Vegan options

 

La Grignote

 

1211 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040

Website  ·  Instagram

 

A French and international cafe-bakery on upper Duval with more than 40 kinds of pastries, from kouign amann and pasteis de nata to bombolini, plus sourdough loaves. The menu labels gluten-free cakes and a gluten-free vegan muffin, and breakfast and lunch run daily until mid-afternoon.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Almond Croissant

 

DUVAL STREET & OLD TOWN

 

Frenchie's Cafe

 

529 United St, Key West, FL 33040

Website

 

A small French cafe on United Street with indoor and outdoor seating, serving breakfast and lunch. The French Breakfast comes with two pastries of your choice, toasted bread, a coffee drink and fresh orange juice.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Almond Croissant

 

DUVAL STREET & OLD TOWN

◉ OFFICIAL UNDERGROUND DONUT TOUR PARTNER

● Gluten-free options

 

Mattheessen's Candy Kitchen (Duval Street)

 

419 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040

Website  ·  Instagram

 

A Key West sweets shop since 1993, known for half-pound cookies made from dough mixed fresh daily. It also sells coconut macaroons, key lime pie with a thick graham cracker crust and marble slab fudge.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Chocolate-Dipped Coconut Macaroon

 

Taste it on our tour →

 

DUVAL STREET & OLD TOWN

 

123 Rico Pastel

 

1128 Simonton St, Key West, FL 33040

 

A small Latin bakery-cafe on Simonton Street, licensed by the state as a retail bakery. The menu covers empanadas, croquetas, cachapas, media noches and flan, served from the morning into early afternoon.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Empanadas

 

KEY WEST HISTORIC SEAPORT

◉ OFFICIAL UNDERGROUND DONUT TOUR PARTNER

● Gluten-free options

 

Kermit's Key Lime Shop (Elizabeth Street)

 

200 Elizabeth St, Key West, FL 33040

Website

 

Kermit Carpenter started selling key lime pie about 30 years ago on the corner of Elizabeth and Greene, near the bight. The Elizabeth Street shop has a shaded patio and koi pond and sells a gluten-free key lime pie alongside the classic.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Key Lime Pie on a Stick Dipped in Chocolate

 

Taste it on our tour →

 

KEY WEST HISTORIC SEAPORT

◉ OFFICIAL UNDERGROUND DONUT TOUR PARTNER

● Gluten-free options

 

Key West Key Lime Pie Co.

 

511 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040

Website  ·  Instagram

 

Pies are made by hand daily from a family recipe with real key lime juice and a handmade graham cracker crust, in flavors like mango, blueberry and toasted coconut. The shop also runs pie-making classes and ships nationwide.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Chocolate-Dipped Key Lime Pie Bar

 

Taste it on our tour →

 

KEY WEST HISTORIC SEAPORT

● Gluten-free options

 

Key Lime Pie Bakery

 

412 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040

Website

 

A locally owned Greene Street shop that bakes key lime pie fresh daily and also sells cakes, cookies, key lime juice and salt water taffy. A gluten-free key lime pie is available, and pies can be shipped.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Key Lime Pie with Homemade Whipped Cream

 

KEY WEST HISTORIC SEAPORT

 

The Baklava

 

411 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040

Instagram

 

A small dessert cafe on Greene Street that makes its baklava from scratch. Greek-style pastries and dessert specials round out the case.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Triangle Baklava with Ice Cream

 

BAHAMA VILLAGE

● Women-owned   ● Gluten-free options   ● Vegan options

 

Moondog Cafe & Bakery

 

823 Whitehead St, Key West, FL 33040

Website  ·  Instagram

 

Jamille Cucci and Dominique Falkner run this cafe next to the Hemingway Home, which earned a Michelin Bib Gourmand in the 2026 Florida guide. The bakery case holds almond, pistachio and creme brulee croissants, a guava and cream cheese danish and Basque cheesecake, with many items labeled gluten-free or vegan.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Mini Vegan Key Lime Pie

 

MIDTOWN & NEW TOWN

 

Goldman's Bagel Deli

 

2796 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL 33040

Website

 

A Jewish-style deli open since 1998 that bakes New York-style bagels fresh every morning. The menu also covers hot pastrami, corned beef, smoked fish and omelettes.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Bagel with Smoked Fish

 

MIDTOWN & NEW TOWN

 

Key West Cakes

 

2510 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL 33040

Website  ·  Instagram

 

A locally owned cake bakery operating since 2001 that bakes cakes, cupcakes and cookies on site. It is known for wedding and custom cakes and offers tastings by appointment.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Cupcakes

 

STOCK ISLAND

 

Croissants de France

 

5620 MacDonald Ave, Key West, FL 33040

Instagram

 

A counter-service French bakery on Stock Island with a shaded, dog-friendly patio, now the only location after the Duval Street shop closed. Croissants come in flavors like coconut cream, banana chocolate, pear almond and guava, alongside daily quiches and crepes.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Coconut Cream Croissant

 

Taste Key West's best on one walk

Skip the guesswork. Our guides pick the best of the best at each stop, with stories along the way.

Key West Southernmost Sweet Treats Tour →

Haunted Key West Food Tour: Sweet Treats & Spooky Stories →

 

Key West Bakery FAQ

Where can I get key lime pie from a bakery in Key West?

Key West Key Lime Pie Co. and Key Lime Pie Bakery on Greene Street make pies daily, and Kermit's on Elizabeth Street sells key lime pie on a stick dipped in chocolate. Old Town Bakery bakes its pie with a gingersnap crust.

 

Where can I find croissants in Key West?

La Grignote on upper Duval bakes several kinds of croissants, Moondog Cafe & Bakery makes pistachio and creme brulee versions, and Croissants de France on Stock Island offers flavors like coconut cream and guava. Frenchie's Cafe is known for its almond croissant.

 

Are there gluten-free or vegan bakery options in Key West?

Yes. Moondog labels many items gluten-free or vegan, including a mini vegan key lime pie, and La Grignote offers gluten-free cakes and a gluten-free vegan muffin. Kermit's, Key Lime Pie Bakery and Key West Key Lime Pie Co. all sell gluten-free key lime pie.

 

Which Key West bakeries open early?

Croissants de France on Stock Island opens at 6:30am, and Old Town Bakery, La Grignote and Frenchie's Cafe open around 7am. Most bakeries close by mid-afternoon, and some take a short break in September and October, so check hours before you go.

 

Does the Underground Donut Tour stop at bakeries in Key West?

Yes. Our Key West Southernmost Sweet Treats Tour stops at Kermit's Key Lime Shop, and our Haunted Key West Food Tour stops at Key West Key Lime Pie Co. and Mattheessen's.

 

Related Articles

Best Donut Shops in Key West  23 shops by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Chicago  25 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Boston  24 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Portland  17 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Seattle  24 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Nashville  18 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in New York City  24 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Washington DC  19 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in New Orleans  18 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Philadelphia  25 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Dublin  18 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Toronto  17 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Cork  17 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Las Vegas  15 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Savannah  17 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Detroit  18 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Vancouver  23 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in London  24 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Miami  24 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Santa Monica  18 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in San Diego  19 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Edinburgh  21 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Victoria  23 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Charleston  23 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Brighton  22 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Pittsburgh  23 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Los Angeles  24 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Santa Fe  18 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Knoxville  17 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Austin  22 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Milwaukee  21 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in San Antonio  20 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Dallas  22 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in Madison  23 bakeries by neighborhood

Key West Donut Tour FAQ  Stops, timing, kids and diets

bottom of page