top of page

Helvetica Light is an easy-to-read font, with tall and narrow letters, that works well on almost every site.

Home › Donut Guides › Ice Cream Guides › Best Ice Cream in New York City

 

Best Ice Cream in New York City

 

From the Lemon Ice King of Corona to Chinatown's lychee and black sesame scoops and Harlem's Black-owned creamery, these are the New York City ice cream, gelato and soft serve shops we send our own friends to. They are grouped by neighborhood, each with our must-try pick.

 

By the Underground Donut Tour team · Updated November 2026

 

Craving donuts too? See our Best Donuts in New York City guide.

 

Want to taste the best of New York City with a guide? See our New York City food tours.

UNION SQUARE / GREENWICH VILLAGE

● Women-owned

 

Caffè Panna

 

77 Irving Pl, New York, NY 10003

Website  ·  Instagram

 

Hallie Meyer opened this Roman-inspired gelateria and espresso bar in Gramercy, a few blocks from Union Square. Flavors are made in-house and change daily, and the shop is known for affogatos and loaded sundaes. A second location operates in Greenpoint.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Affogato (scoop of the day drowned in espresso); Caffè Bianco Stracciatella

 

NOHO / EAST VILLAGE

● Vegan options   ● Viral on social media

 

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream (East Village)

 

48 1/2 E 7th St, New York, NY 10003

Website  ·  Instagram  ·  Facebook

 

Van Leeuwen started as a yellow ice cream truck in 2008 and this narrow East Village scoop shop is one of its original storefronts. The brand makes French-style ice cream with extra egg yolks alongside a full line of vegan flavors made from cashew and oat milk.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Sicilian Pistachio; seasonal Mango Sticky Rice

 

NOHO / EAST VILLAGE

● Vegan options

 

Davey's Ice Cream (East Village)

 

309 E 9th St, New York, NY 10003

Website  ·  Instagram  ·  Facebook

 

Owner David Yoo makes small-batch ice cream from scratch, and the shop moved from First Avenue to this 9th Street storefront in 2022. The menu mixes classics like strong coffee and deep dark double chocolate with rotating flavors and ice cream sandwiches. A second shop is in Greenpoint.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Strong Coffee; Deep Dark Double Chocolate

 

NOHO / EAST VILLAGE

 

Sundaes and Cones

 

95 E 10th St, New York, NY 10003

 

This long-running scoop shop near Third Avenue offers more than 30 flavors that range from classics to Asian-inspired picks like black sesame, green tea and wasabi. It is a reliable stop for sundaes and banana boats close to Astor Place.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Black sesame; Banana Boat sundae

 

SOHO / NOLITA / LOWER EAST SIDE

● Viral on social media

 

Soft Swerve (Lower East Side)

 

85B Allen St, New York, NY 10002

Website

 

Childhood friends Jason Liu and Michael Tsang opened Soft Swerve on Allen Street in 2016 and grew it into a small chain of Asian-inspired soft serve shops. Its purple ube soft serve became an Instagram favorite, and Yelp ranked it the No. 2 most-saved ice cream shop in the U.S. in 2026.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Ube soft serve, often swirled with black sesame

 

SOHO / NOLITA / LOWER EAST SIDE

● Vegan options

 

Morgenstern's Finest Ice Cream

 

2 Rivington St, New York, NY 10002

Website  ·  Instagram  ·  Facebook

 

Nicholas Morgenstern closed his Houston Street flagship in October 2025 and reopened in 2026 on Rivington Street, back in the neighborhood where the shop began. The smaller parlor scoops from noon to midnight daily and keeps cult flavors alongside new ones like caramelized crème fraîche. Dairy-free sorbets are part of the lineup.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Bitter Black Chocolate Ash; Olive Oil Chocolate Sorbet

 

SOHO / NOLITA / LOWER EAST SIDE

● Vegan options

 

Il Laboratorio del Gelato

 

188 Ludlow St, New York, NY 10002

Website  ·  Instagram  ·  Facebook

 

Founded by Jon Snyder in 2002, this Ludlow Street gelato maker has a recipe library approaching 300 flavors and rotates through them in the scoop case. Expect unusual picks like Thai chili chocolate, Earl Grey and butternut squash next to classic pistachio and sorbets. Yelp ranked it the No. 6 most-saved ice cream shop in the U.S. in 2026.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Thai Chili Chocolate; Earl Grey

 

SOHO / NOLITA / LOWER EAST SIDE

 

Julia Jean's

 

202 Clinton St, New York, NY 10002

 

Ice cream maker Ayanna Quint opened this retro sundae parlor in 2025 and named it after her mother. The menu sticks to classic scoops, shakes, ice cream sandwiches and banana splits.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Butter pecan; The Otis sundae (chocolate chip cookie, salted caramel, whipped cream)

 

CHINATOWN

● Asian-owned   ● Women-owned

 

Chinatown Ice Cream Factory

 

65 Bayard St, New York, NY 10013

Website  ·  Instagram  ·  Facebook

 

The Seid family has run this Bayard Street shop since the late 1970s, making ice cream in flavors like lychee, almond cookie, pandan and red bean. Christina Seid took over from her father in 2002 and added flavors such as durian, egg custard and black sesame.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Black sesame; Almond Cookie; Durian

 

CHINATOWN

● Viral on social media

 

Taiyaki NYC (Chinatown)

 

119 Baxter St, New York, NY 10013

Website  ·  Instagram  ·  Facebook

 

Taiyaki NYC serves soft serve inside a fish-shaped Japanese waffle cone, and its Baxter Street shop helped make the cones an internet sensation. Toppings include mochi, red bean and wafer pieces.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Black sesame soft serve with red bean in a taiyaki cone

 

MIDTOWN / TIMES SQUARE

 

Sundaes Best

 

4 E 32nd St, New York, NY 10016

 

This Koreatown gelato shop blends Italian technique with Korean and Asian ingredients and keeps about 30 gelatos and sorbets in rotation. Flavors include injeolmi with rice cake pieces, miso caramel and makgeolli.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Miso caramel gelato; Injeolmi

 

UPPER MANHATTAN

● Black-owned   ● Vegan options

 

Sugar Hill Creamery (Central Harlem)

 

184 Malcolm X Blvd, New York, NY 10026

Website  ·  Instagram  ·  Facebook

 

Husband-and-wife team Petrushka Bazin Larsen and Nick Larsen opened this Harlem scoop shop in 2017, with flavors inspired by Caribbean and Midwestern roots and named for Harlem culture. The shop is open year-round and has additional locations in West and East Harlem.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Chairperson of the Board (blueberry cheesecake); A$AP Rocky Road

 

UPPER MANHATTAN

 

Lexington Candy Shop

 

1226 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10028

Website  ·  Instagram

 

Open on the Upper East Side since 1925, this family-run luncheonette has a vintage soda fountain counter. It makes its own chocolate syrup for egg creams and serves malts, ice cream sodas and sundaes.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Chocolate egg cream

 

WILLIAMSBURG / GREENPOINT

● Women-owned

 

The Screen Door (Greenpoint)

 

145 Driggs Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222

Website  ·  Instagram

 

Greenpoint local Kate Covey runs this nostalgic soft serve stand near McGolrick Park. The menu covers flurries, sundaes, shakes and pup cups. Open seasonally: the Greenpoint stand closes for winter and reopens in spring, while the Sunnyside location stays open.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Reese's Fluffernutter Flurry Sundae; Orange Freeze

 

WILLIAMSBURG / GREENPOINT

 

Common Meadows Creamery

 

227 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11211

Website  ·  Instagram

 

This family-run gelato maker supplied NYC restaurants and sold at Smorgasburg before opening its first shop in Williamsburg in late 2025. The menu changes daily, with about 10 gelatos and sorbets at a time.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Black sesame gelato; seasonal honeydew sorbet

 

BED-STUY / BROOKLYN HEIGHTS

● Black-owned   ● Vegan options

 

Island Pops

 

670 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216

Website  ·  Instagram

 

Trinidad-born couple Shelly Marshall and Khalid Hamid opened this Crown Heights shop in 2015 to recreate the ice creams and pops of their childhood. The menu leans Caribbean with soursop, Guinness caramel, grapenut and sorrel, plus a rotating set of vegan flavors.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Soursop ice cream; Guinness caramel

 

SOUTH BROOKLYN

 

L'Albero dei Gelati

 

341 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Website

 

This Park Slope gelateria is a branch of a family gelato shop from Seregno, near Milan, run by Monia Solighetto, Alessandro Trezza and pastry chef Marco Iannantuoni. It uses local dairy and is known for savory experiments like blue cheese and bell pepper next to classic nut flavors.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Butter and salt; Gianduia

 

SOUTH BROOKLYN

● Women-owned   ● Asian-owned

 

Malai (Carroll Gardens)

 

268 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

Website  ·  Instagram  ·  Facebook

 

Pooja Bavishi, a first-generation Indian American, founded Malai to build ice creams around South Asian spices and aromatics. The Smith Street flagship scoops eggless ice cream in flavors like rose with cinnamon roasted almonds, masala chai and saffron pistachio.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Rose with Cinnamon Roasted Almonds; Masala Chai

 

SOUTH BROOKLYN

 

Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain

 

513 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

Website  ·  Instagram

 

Siblings Peter Freeman and Gia Giasullo opened this soda fountain in a restored 1920s Carroll Gardens apothecary in 2010. It serves house-made sodas, floats and over-the-top sundaes, and its egg cream won the National Egg Cream Invitational in 2025.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Chocolate egg cream; specialty sundaes

 

SOUTH BROOKLYN

● Vegan options

 

Mr. P's Homemade Ice Cream

 

1397 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11226

Website  ·  Instagram  ·  Facebook

 

Trinidad-born Patrick Victor started selling ice cream from a pushcart and now runs this Little Caribbean shop with his sons. Flavors draw on island ingredients like soursop, sorrel ginger, sea moss and grapenut, and vegan options are made with oat milk and agave.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Soursop

 

QUEENS

● Vegan options

 

The Lemon Ice King of Corona

 

52-02 108th St, Corona, NY 11368

Website

 

Nicola Benfaremo started selling Italian ices in Corona in 1944, and current owners Mike Zampino and Vincent Barbaccia keep dozens of flavors in the walk-up window. Lemon is still the top seller, with peanut butter, rainbow and cherry close behind.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Lemon ice; Peanut Butter ice

 

QUEENS

 

Eddie's Sweet Shop

 

105-29 Metropolitan Ave, Forest Hills, NY 11375

Website

 

This Forest Hills parlor has served ice cream at the same corner since the 1920s and has been run by the Citrano family since 1968. It keeps its marble counter, swivel stools and tin ceiling, and makes its own syrups and whipped cream.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Banana Royal sundae; malted milkshake

 

QUEENS

 

FIGO il Gelato Italiano

 

29-02 23rd Ave, Astoria, NY 11105

 

Italian couple Francesco D'Ambrosio and Liliana Buscemi opened this Astoria gelateria in 2017 using a Sicilian-style family recipe with ingredients imported from Italy. Yelp ranked it the No. 11 most-saved ice cream shop in the U.S. in 2026.

 

Donut Tour Recommends: Pistachio; Stracciatella

 

Taste New York City's best on one walk

Skip the guesswork. Our guides pick the best of the best at each stop, with stories along the way.

Union Square Delicious Donut Tour →

Union Square Choose Your Own Donuts Tour →

East Village Delicious Donut & Pastry Tour →

Times Square Delicious Donut Tour →

Brooklyn Delicious Donut & History Tour →

Midtown Holiday Donut Tour →

 

New York City Ice Cream FAQ

What is a New York egg cream?

An egg cream is a fountain drink of chocolate or vanilla syrup, cold milk and seltzer, and despite the name it contains no egg or cream. Classic soda fountains like Lexington Candy Shop and Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain still make them by hand.

 

What are Italian ices, and where can I try them?

Italian ice is a smooth, scoopable frozen dessert made from fruit, sugar and water, closer to sorbet than ice cream. The Lemon Ice King of Corona in Queens has served it since 1944, and lemon is still its top seller.

 

Are NYC ice cream shops open in winter?

Most year-round shops in Manhattan and Brooklyn stay open, though many shorten hours or close early in the week from November to March. Seasonal spots like The Screen Door in Greenpoint close for the cold months, so check hours before you go.

 

Where can I find dairy-free or vegan ice cream in NYC?

Van Leeuwen has a full line of vegan flavors, and Sugar Hill Creamery, Island Pops and Mr. P's all scoop vegan options. Gelato shops like Il Laboratorio del Gelato also offer dairy-free sorbets.

 

Which NYC shops make Asian-inspired ice cream?

Chinatown Ice Cream Factory has scooped flavors like lychee, black sesame and durian since the 1970s, and Soft Swerve is known for its purple ube soft serve. Sundaes Best in Koreatown and Malai in Carroll Gardens put Korean and South Asian ingredients into their scoops.

 

Related Articles

Best Donuts in New York City  28 shops by neighborhood

Best Bakeries in New York City  24 bakeries by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Chicago  24 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Boston  24 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Portland  18 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Seattle  22 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Nashville  19 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Washington DC  19 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in New Orleans  19 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Philadelphia  22 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Dublin  16 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Toronto  21 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Las Vegas  21 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Savannah  13 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Detroit  19 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Vancouver  24 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in London  21 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Miami  22 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Santa Monica  19 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in San Diego  18 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Edinburgh  16 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Victoria  15 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Charleston  18 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Brighton  13 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Pittsburgh  20 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Los Angeles  24 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Knoxville  15 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Austin  18 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Milwaukee  20 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in San Antonio  21 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Dallas  20 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream in Madison  16 ice cream shops by neighborhood

Best Ice Cream & Frozen Treats in Key West  14 ice cream shops by neighborhood

New York City Donut Tour FAQ  Stops, timing, kids and diets

bottom of page